Best Restaurant in Tulsa

Bagels Worth Bragging About!

Order Online

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Bagel with Cream Cheese

Regular or low fat

Add Item

Ham & Cream Cheese Bagel

Add Item

Meatlovers Bagel

Mixture of bacon, ham, & sausage with egg & melted white cheddar

Add Item

Bruschetta Chicken

Roasted chicken, Parmesan cheese, pesto mayo, served hot

Add Item

Pizza Bagel

Served open faced with pizza sauce & mozzarella

Dozen Bagels

8 oz Cream Cheese

Dozen Cookies

Chorizo Bagel

chorizo sausage, egg, sliced tomato, fresh avocado, melted cheddar

Add Item

Introducing New York Bagel Cafe 🥯

Hey there! If you're on the hunt for a taste of authentic New York bagels right here in South Tulsa and Brookside, look no further than New York Bagel Cafe. We're not newbies to the bagel game - we've been serving up those classic, chewy-on-the-inside, crispy-on-the-outside bagels for almost 13 years now! You might've known us as Old School Bagel, but hey, we're going back to our roots with the name change. We're bringing back that classic New York Bagel Cafe vibe, one bite at a time.

Slice Of Doughy Heaven Right Here!

What's our specialty, you ask? Bagels, bagels, and more bagels! Picture this: a fresh batch of New York-style bagels, boiled and baked to perfection, just waiting for you to sink your teeth into. Whether you're a cream cheese connoisseur or a fan of classic lox, we've got a bagel for every craving.

Different Name, Same Delicious Game

Sure, our name might be changing, but one thing remains the same: our commitment to serving up the best darn bagels in town. We're still your go-to spot for that cozy, hometown bagel cafe experience. So, swing by and say hi - we're excited to continue being your favorite Tulsa-owned bagel joint!

Dine-In or Take-Out

Life's a whirlwind, but your bagel fix doesn't have to be! We're here to make it easy-peasy, bagel squeezy. Whether you're chilling in our cozy cafe or snagging a bagel to-go for a dash, we've got your back. And hey, when the sun's shining, why not savor your bagel in the great outdoors? It's bagels, bites, and bliss – all in one tasty stop!

Order Now & Let the Good Times Roll 🛒

Ready to get your hands on some freshly baked bagel goodness? Ordering from New York Bagel Cafe is as easy as pie (or, you guessed it, easy as bagels). Simply hop online, place your order, and get ready to experience the taste of New York Bagels. Whether you're a classic connoisseur or a flavor trailblazer, we've got the bagel of your dreams waiting. Get ready to taste, one bite at a time! Our Locations: 📍6805 S Yale Ave Tulsa, OK 74136 📍3723 S Peoria Ave Tulsa, OK 74105

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

Order Now

What our guests are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Y'all. Come eat here!! How have l not been here before? It's fantastic! Love the food, vibe and service!! Fun views, too. There's a patio available as well that's good size!

Heather R.

This bagel shop was delicious. They have a great variety of bagels and both breakfast and lunch sandwich options. Also, there are a number of different coffee flavor options! The restaurant had a nice relaxed vibe with a decent amount of seating to hang out. Quality restaurant, I would definitely recommend.

Kasey S.

Great chill and warm atmosphere. Best bagel I have ever had, onion on the everything breakfast bagel was a great touch. My wifes bday breakfast was on point, chill morning capped off with a wonderful coffee. Java chip frozen mixed coffee was really good, cant wait to come back.